Joobs.ro Blog

12 Apr, 2009

OpenID Pro and Con

After crowling some websites and since we planning on using OpenID, here’s what we’ve found:

PRO

- Email is generally not required for most OpenID-enabled sites currently.
- No email back-and-forth. Convenience
- Keep track of which sites have what information centrally
- Stop typing in all your personal info again and again
- Your OpenID can actually build up a reputation because it is linked to you.
- Site-wide registration. With OpenID you can authorise the entire domain, then each service, provided it has OpenID support would automatically be authenticated.
- You probably already have one

CONS

- Though you have one, there are not many places to use it (yet)
- The sign-in process can be very confusing and jarring to users
- With OpenID, even thought you can maintain multiple identities, you are inherently tying a lot of services together and thus losing some amount of anonymity

What do you think? You can respond in Romanian as well :)

Aboneaza-te la RSS • Adauga comentariu

Citeste si articolele:

  • Google Sites
  • Google Sites iti permite sa editezi chiar si un resume. Un exemplu live: http://sites.google.com/a/altostrat.com/jkraus/Resume Nu suntem impresionati. [...]

  • Email Standards Project
  • http://www.email-standards.org/ “Our goal is to help designers understand why web standards are so important for email, while working with email client[...]

  • Concurs pentru programatorul din tine II
  • Zilele trecute scriam de HTC Magic si concursul initiat de gadgeteer.roVa propuneam sa faceti o aplicatie pentru concurs. Uita de[...]

7 Raspunsuri la "OpenID Pro and Con"

1 | ibz

April 12th, 2009 at 2:18 pm

Avatar

Nr 3 from your list of cons is, I would say, the most important one! That was the reason I never gave much credit to OpenID in the first place. Why? Well, supporters of OpenID say the good part is that you don’t need multiple accounts. You know what? I DO want multiple accounts and I don’t see any benefit of having them “linked together”. Too lazy to type passwords? That’s bs. Firefox remembers the passwords anyway. So what’s the real benefit then?

2 | silvius

April 12th, 2009 at 2:30 pm

Avatar

@ibz My only PRO would be for “Site-wide registration” since I’m having multiple, but separated section on a web service. The OpenID would help people sign in from the same account.

The issue CONS is (tested) that the registration with OpenID is somewhat difficult.

3 | ibz

April 12th, 2009 at 4:26 pm

Avatar

@silvius Well… every cookie from a domain is sent back to every site on that domain, so I don’t really see the benefit of “With OpenID you can authorise the entire domain”. Are you actually talking about SUBdomains?

As for the registration being difficult. It might be – if you tell ordinary users “you need an OpenID account”. But if you tell them “just use your Yahoo or whatever account”, they don’t even have to register, since they most probably have one of these accounts already. Check stackoverflow.com. It does a pretty good job when asking you to sign up with OpenID.

4 | Razvan Girmacea

April 12th, 2009 at 5:09 pm

Avatar

I am agains OpenID for now. Wanted to try it but figured out that I will actually loose users because it is confusing (going to google/yahoo page) … “simple” people are looking to register and login. They are not used to already beeing registered.

But OpenID will be great in couple of years I think.

5 | xuedi

April 12th, 2009 at 8:07 pm

Avatar

@ibz, i must agree with you, nowadays you have intelligent browsers (not ie ;-) who save passwords for you, if not, you have password manager …

The idea to have all your private, business and or fun accounts linked together is quite scary!

Cheers
xuedi

6 | silvius

April 13th, 2009 at 9:15 am

Avatar

@Razvan Would be more helpfull to login with a gmail account? Also is better to allow people to choose password or to generate one that they will be able to change. Same question goes to others. I’m curious what you guys think.

@xuedi No matter how we “protect” still our level of privacy goes down with the years..

7 | Razvan Girmacea

April 13th, 2009 at 10:28 am

Avatar

Think of it as RSS vs normal reading a blog. Clearly RSS is better, but 90% of internet users don’t use a RSS reader and don’t know what RSS is and they will read the blog the same way they are used to, by going directly to the website. I have discussed this with my friends and did some polls.
Same goes for OpenID.

Comentarii

Despre

Blog despre recrutare, beneficii si salarizare in IT, despre antreprenoriat si tehnologii.
Subscribe to RSS  RSS    Subscribe to Twitter  Twitter    Subscribe to Facebook  Facebook    Subscribe to LinkedIn  LinkedIn

Articole recente

  • Te invitam la Open Agile
  • Te invitam la Open Agile, eveniment Agile, Lean, Software craftsmanship dedicat imbunatatirii dezvoltarii de software. Evenimentul organizat de Mosaic Works...

  • Locuri
  • Cind lucrezi in afara biroului, ce loc preferi? Cautam locuri frumoase, unde sa poti sta relaxat si sa lucrezi pentru cateva...

  • Preturi si salarii de demult
  • Acum peste 20 si ceva de ani: Salariul mediu 2000 lei Berea 3-5 lei Cinema 3-6 lei Bicicleta 800-1000 lei TV alb-negru 2000-4000 lei Prajitura 2...

Comentarii recente



Urmareste-ne pe Twitter